The Point of No Return – Phantom of the Opera





The marquee on the Yonge St. entrance
It had been a while since I’d seen the show at the Pantages…more than a year, actually! Even so, most of the cast was pretty familiar. David Rogers had come back as Raoul for the last week of performances. The major new people were Melissa Dye as Christine, and, of course, Paul Stanley as the Phantom. I thought Melissa was a fine Christine. Better than some, worse than some, but overall, not bad. And, this being the final night of the show in Toronto, she was quite emotional…though maybe she’s always emotional, I don’t know.

I was prepared to be disappointed with Paul Stanley’s Phantom, but he actually impressed me quite a bit in some parts. Vocally, he was quite good. His acting wasn’t bad either, though it seemed to me that he was just trying too hard. Erik is supposed to look effortless, and that’s one word I would not use to describe Paul’s Phantom. His final lair scene was probably the weakest point, but I still cried…because it was the final show? I don’t know.

At the end of the show, there were some short speeches, and then the entire cast sang Music of the Night before the fireworks, streamers, balloons, etc. It was very moving to hear the whole cast sing “It’s over now, the music of the night” as the last words of the night.

There had been an auction in the lobby of the Pantages before the show, and there was another one afterwards at the Windsor Arms hotel. I didn’t buy anything, as most everything was out of my price range, or would just be impractical to get home (right, Beth? :-), but it was still really neat to see everything. And I got to talk to Laird Mackintosh briefly at intermission, so that was nice. All in all, it was an enjoyable day, and I’m going to miss seeing the show at the Pantages!!


The Quotes:

“You don’t want that one…who would want a Hannibal poster?”
Beth and I, trying to discourage people from bidding on the poster she wanted. 🙂

“Si, these things do happen! All the time! For the past *ten* years, these things do happen!”
Kim Stengel, during the show

“I’m the last one to join, and I get to talk first!”
Paul Stanley, during curtain call

The Pictures:


The side of the Pantages


The Pantages, on the day of the last show


The auction in the lobby of the theatre


Me, Glenda Balkan, Beth and Sandra Margolese at the auction


Dave, me, Catherine, Beth and Kristen before the show


Kim Stengel’s bow


David Rogers’ bow


Melissa Dye’s bow


Paul Stanley’s bow


The cast’s last bow at the Pantages



The cast:


The Phantom of the Opera

PAUL STANLEY

Christine Daaé

MELISSA DYE

Raoul, Vicomte de Chagny

DAVID ROGERS

Carlotta Giudicelli

KIM STENGEL

Monsieur André

PAUL MULLOY

Monsieur Firmin

TERRY HODGES

Madame Giry

KRISTINA MARIE GUIGUET

Ubaldo Piangi

BRENT WEBER

Meg Giry

CATRIONA DERGUSON

Monsieur Reyer

GERALD ISAAC

Don Attilio (“Il Muto”)/Passarino

SCOTT WATANABE

Porter/Marksman

BRIAN C. DUYN

Monsieur Lefèvre

DAVID PLAYFAIR

Auctioneer/Joseph Buquet

JOHN DODINGTON

Lion Man/Fireman

KELLY ROBERTSON

Slave Master (“Hannibal”)

KIRK HANSEN

Flunky/Stagehand

CHRISTOPHER KISS

Policeman

ROBERT MEILLEUR

Page (“Don Juan Triumphant”)

JULIA JAMISON

Porter/Fireman

BRAD CORMIER

Page (“Don Juan Triumphant”)

TANIA PARRISH

Wardrobe Mistress/Confidante (“Il Muto”)

LISA GAASENBEEK

Princess (“Hannibal”)

SANDRA MARGOLESE

Madame Firmin

JANET COATES

Inkeeper’s Wife (“Don Juan Triumphant”)

JILL DIANE FILION

The Ballet Chorus of the Opera Populaire

SAMANTHA ADAMSON
HARRIET CHUNG
PHILIPPA HAYBALL
DONNA KELLY
DEANNA PIDWERBESKI
MIMI F. PINEAU

Dance Captain/Ballet Swing

ANITA BOSTOK

Phantom Experience Index